Wait guys, so I was just doing some more research about the wing feather saga recently. And I know a lot of people are saying that it’s more probable that Janner came back to life. But I found out that it’s actually the opposite while there is optimism that he might have come back to life then it is more definite that he didn’t because when you look it up then once Janner died the books ended and when Andrew Peterson was asked about this, he said no the wingfeather saga is complete.. clearly there could be optimism or different perspectives on how different readers read the books but canonly janner does not come back to life and I think it’s kind of demeaning to the story for everybody to pretend that he does which I understand it’s sad and I was in denial about it too but it’s a pivotal point in the story and assuming that he comes back to life is pretty dangerous. I definitely think that there’s a possibility he could have come back to life but when you read the ending of book 4 more closely and you pay attention to the behaviour and the tone of the story it’s pretty evident that it’s more likely than not that he does not come back to life. :(
top of page
bottom of page
Here's what I think:
Janner comes back to life. My reasons? Keep reading to find out.
1. In OtEotDSoD, when Nugget was run through, I believe that Nugget died. He was literally run through with a spear. Run through with a spear, and we have NO idea how long it was before Peet found him! It could have been anywhere from thirty minutes to two hours. Then he had to go back to his treehouse to get the water, which probably took around six hours, based on how long it took for Peet to get the water for Podo from Anklejelly, (which was closer to his house by a lot!), and then he had to get back to the dog. In all, Nugget could have lain there from 12 hours and 30 minutes to 14 hours. That dog was dead. The water had to have resurrected him, and, as a bonus, made Nugget the size of a horse
2. It's ruin the story if Janner didn't come back
3. Janner's sacrifice was sort of a representation of Jesus' sacrifice. I'm not saying Janner was anywhere near perfect, but he had no fangness in him. In theory, Leeli could have also sacrificed herself. But in the story of Jesus' death and resurrection, (WOOO), Jesus came back, which is my biggest point.