Spoilers for Finale: A realization about Chptr 64

Apr 20

•

Replying to

**sympathetically pats you on your shoulder*

Lili Shakespeare the Provider of Caffeinated Beverages(FF, FAR, BLC, ASC)

Apr 20

•

Replying to

relatable😭

Apr 20

•

Replying to

offers a tray of cookies I know. Nobody's dead.

Apr 19

•

she gotta be a special kinda ugly if that's the case😭 especially if he did survive. Personally I think he did but that's probably me not willing to except his death. I was traumatized after finishing that book, for days I mourned the loss of Janner😂 part of the reason that I think the well does work is at the end Kalmar seems so hopeful that he'll be with his brother again. I can't imagine the Wingfeather family going on an adventure after the last book just for it to fail. That'd be like Janner dying all over again, i refuse to except that. Also I'm currently rereading TWatWK and I'm dreading coming to the end😭part of me wants to just read 90% of the book and skip the end...if i don't read it, it didn't happen.

Anaya Wingfeather the Cheerleader (FF, FAR, ASC, BLT, AMLC)

Apr 27

•

Replying to

usually my play swords were massive bamboo trunks...branches...sticks...idk what they'd be called but ye i have multiple scars from fighting with those things. Also if ur wondering why we have them my mom uses them in her garden for vines to grow up😂

lol must be related...idk its fun do stuff in random places that arent normal...like being on a roof. Thats definitely a good reason to not be on ur roof tho thats awesome. My grandma lives with us too shes like in a separate house that connected to ours. its like an apartment on one side of our house. I feel like ive heard of that but no ive never read it

ye i was wondering that, i mean its cool that u get to meet so many different people but its only like once. Its good that u keep in touch with each other but its definitely not the same as hanging out with them. Thats awesome!! everyone needs friends in my opinion!!

I know its soo sad!!!!😭 dont worry im working on it tho!!!!

Apr 28

•

Replying to

bahah yoo dass LEGENDARY!! honestly, we used sticks (more like staffs) from my dads woodshop (right next to our house) more than the sword cuz they were fun to spin and whack with lol

fr tho we must- and thats so true!! im like singing at the top of my lungs is sooo much more fun when im in on a roof then normally

eheh ye i really need to get that done soon lol

yooo we have an apartment on one side of our house TOO!!! THATS CRAZY!! my older sis is currently staying there tho

its really good- i enjoyed it a lot!!

fr fr, but i try to look mostly at the bright side! and it also helps me realize how much a first impression lasts if you never see them again- so i've started being more aware of how i make people feel and what they might remember of me

and YAAH MANN THEY ARE AWESOME!!!

good. you better be.

Gracie W. Beit The Freedom Warrior (FAR co-founder) (1/2 FF)

Apr 30

•

Replying to

swords are definitely necessary for every childhood, they're absolutely marvelous!!!

thats awesome tho i love that!!!

oh ye 100% singing out of place is far more enjoyable

dont rush it tho enjoy it!!!

ok...bre...this is insane. All of these similarities and now we live in the same house?!?!?!

bro ive gotten so many good book recommendations I need to start a list

looking on the bright side is just way for fun anyway!!

im like 5 chapters into TWatWK and its been like a week😂😭

also @Anaya Wingfeather the Cheerleader (FF, FAR, ASC) why dont we just @ each other cuz i feel like posts get buried and then i dont respond because it just gets lost. And i feel bad when that happens😭

Apr 19

•

I think that's proof he lives longer, but there is a ton of evidence that I found, I made a post about it...

Ellie (FF, ASC)

Apr 19

•

Maybe it haunted him for the rest of his life that lasted more than just one more week?

Apr 19

•

Replying to

Maybe, but if the well didn't work, then... ouch. It's like a retroactive slap, lol

Ellie (FF, ASC)

Apr 19

•

Replying to

Do you think he comes back to life? I for one do.

Edited

Mr. Banana [FR, HK, HORC, NPP, ST, SA (of SIA and CIA.) ect.]

Apr 19

•

Replying to

I'm not exactly sure. Speaking from a meta-perspective and as an aspiring author, I feel like Andrew kinda painted this question into a corner (maybe accidentally, maybe not).

See, if Janner is revived, then how can you tell that story in an interesting way? What is the tension and the conflict driving that tale? Somehow, you need to drag out the situation and add some sort of plot, but there isn't anything setting up a conflict. So, the story would sadly fall flat.

But if Janner died? Well, then you can't very well tell a story that's just about that; you should've left out the possibility of resuscitation all together if that was the plan. So the well should work if you're going to tell that story.

But maybe you just timeskip ahead? Well, if the well worked, then timeskipping past that would feel disorienting and weird. But if it failed, then that will have to add a mournful note to the story, and if it's the point of the story, then you'll have to tell a sad, contemplative tale.

It's just a really tricky situation to write through, I feel. Which basically just means we're left in limbo unless/until someone can walk through that path very carefully.

Apr 19

•

That may be a hint that Janner survives as the statement loses a lot of meaning if he dies a week later.

Apr 19

•

Replying to

Or maybe that sentence just doesn't have a lot of meaning. Or maybe Andrew Peterson used it cause it sounds cool. I do that sometimes.

Apr 19

•

Replying to

Perhaps, but it could also serve as a dark and secretive hint to the fact that he doesn't live for much longer (and thus has no time to move past this event)

Apr 19

•

Replying to

Apr 19

•

And your conclusion is . . . ?

Edited

Apr 19

•

Replying to

Nothing in particular. It was more of an "oof" moment, considering that for all we know, Janner might be dead for good. (Maybe not, but Peterson won't tell... the absolute nerve! Tut tut....)