I finished The Prince of Yorsha Doon. It was really good. I liked it. Now I'm reading The Wooing of Sophelia Stupe, and there's a plot hole. It mentions Edd Helmer, the father of Podo Helmer, but this story is set in the Third Epoch, so that would mean that Podo would be born about 400-700 years into Edd's life, which does NOT make sense at all, unless Podo is REALLY old. And also, in OtEotDSoD, it says that the Igiby Cottage was built by Podo's great-great-great-grandparents, but in WFT, it says that it was built by Edd Helmer. So I thought that there must be two Edds: Edd Helmer I (Podo's great-great-great-grandfather) and Edd Helmer II (Podo's father). But that theory was dashed to pieces when I read the line "I'll never finish that cottage for Yamsa now." This line tells us that Edd I's wife's name is Yamsa, the same name as Edd II's wife, so it would be a HUGE coincidence if they were different people because their wives would have the same name. 🍪
top of page
bottom of page
Keep in mind, the Wooing of Sophelia Stupe wasn't written by Andrew Peterson! I would guess that he didn't catch that in editing.
*brain processes*
oHHH YOU'RE RIGHT-
That does look like a plothole, but I guess it could be a coincidance.
Sam, you have a skill for finding any and all plot holes in books.
😂😂😂
ANDREW PETERSON HOW COULD YOU--
.......... why are finding plot holes?!?! I was perfectly content not knowing that!!! 😭😭😭🤣🤣🤣
Hmmm... Well, I am going to assume it is a coincidence because otherwise I will just get frustrated, and all the fruit in my house will dissappear about ten times faster. That would not be helpful to my frustration. I mean, my family knows two couples who have the same first and last names, and it could totally happen in Glipwood, so that is what I am going with.
I'm glad you like it! Just wait till you get to the last one tho . . .
It's a big coincidence. 😳 Also, Edd and Yamsa were very popular names in a Glipwood! People gave their kids those names for generations! No plot holes!!!
Ooh. I never noticed that. Granted, I only read it once.