To test this feature, visit your live site.

The ending of book 4 😔

Hey guys, I’m relatively new here, but I just wanted to know your guys’s thoughts on the ending of the warden and the Wolf King. I don’t wanna spoil it for people who haven’t finished the series yet, but we all know that the ending was kind of a slap in the face. I mean me personally I cried for a while, but I also know that it was a good ending. Even though Janner has been my favorite character for almost 5 years and he will continue to be my favorite character. I do think that the ending was perfect. It highlighted all of Jenners amazing qualities and proved that he really would do anything for his little brother. Also, when they were talking about the seed being planted that needed to happen in order to save the world I just don’t think it would be the same effect if Kalmar had saved everyone. I do wish that there was an alternative way, but I’m not sure I give full respect to Andrew Peterson. And I love the books so I can’t complain. I just remember that it was really really sad for me. But what are your thoughts?

35 comments

35 Comments

Batwhacker the Freedom Fighter ✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨

Mar 22

•

**cuddles Maraly* I bawled for, like, an hour and then very affirmatively decided that Janner lives.

Lili Shakespeare (FF and FAR)

Mar 21

•

cradles the baby chorkney that was on my head a moment ago

I did not physically cry. Mentally and emotionally, I was in shock.

As my fellows hath proclaimed, 'tis evidence in Mr. Peterson's masterful mastery for the happier ending.

Lili Shakespeare (FF and FAR)

Mar 23

•

Replying to

grins He is! Marcus is about 3 months old. In another two he'll start rapidly growing. By the time he's eight months, Marcus will be big enough for some of the kids to ride.

Ellie, I'm better!! smiles at how much of a Throne Warden you are and how I'd do the exact same thing, also being a TW

I...don't actually know. (at all. Do you have any ideas?) I'll give him a call!!

Ellie (FF, ASC)

Mar 24

•

Replying to

… I don’t know that’s why I’m asking you.

Lili Shakespeare (FF and FAR)

•

Replying to

My old pal Jeff said he had some necklaces that I can give the chorkneys. He says they've been tested and they just came in. 😀

Mr. Banana [FR, HK, HORC, ST, SA (of SIA and CIA.)]

Mar 21

•

First off what is your opinion on Janner and the water from the first well, and can I change your mind?

Mr. Banana [FR, HK, HORC, ST, SA (of SIA and CIA.)]

•

Replying to

Yup I agree that Andrew Peterson left it up to us. But Janner's sacrifice was a shadow of Jesus's death, so I think that the resurection would happen as well. At the point of his death Janner was satisfied with whatever happened because it would be the Makers will. If it was the makers will for them to find the well and for the water to work, then it would take nothing from the sacrifice. And to be honest the story is kinda sad enough already.

Vee

•

Replying to

Yeah, I hundred percent agree well, I don’t think that Janner 100% articulates Jesus I do think that he shadows him in a way. But I do agree that Jan very well could’ve been resurrected. It’s just not definite which I think a lot of people think it is

Mr. Banana [FR, HK, HORC, ST, SA (of SIA and CIA.)]

•

Replying to

I definitely think it is definite in my tiny universe cause i've made up my mind, but as for the overall definite answer... well it doesn't exist. Everyone's got their own imagination, and if they prefer a sad ending over a happy ending or have their own odd reasons (or conspiracys) then they can imaginate all of that that suits their personal input perfectly and then everyone is happy. Of course it works different in irl land... that's odd...

Wren [LR, TW, CE, BW]

Mar 21

•

I do love the ending but it was very sad. ....but am I the only one didn't cry? ...or like doesnt cry when you read other books....or sometimes even movies? Maybe its just me tho

Fab (HS)

Mar 21

•

Replying to

heh

Gracie W. Beit The Freedom Warrior (FAR co-founder) (1/2 FF)

Mar 22

•

Replying to

I didn't cry. I read the entire series in an afternoon and then was just shocked for a while. I feel with you, I don't feel much emotion during movies and books (except excitement and second hand embarrassment)

Wren [LR, TW, CE, BW]

Mar 22

•

Replying to

I do feel emotion like sadness towards the events but it just never makes me cry

Ickaw Warden

Mar 21

•

It made me cry, but I think it was a beautiful ending all the same.

However, I think there is evidence to suggest that something happens afterward... and I wrote a fanfic called Hope in Deep Waters about what might happen

Edited

Vee

Mar 24

•

Replying to

That’s so cool!!!! I would love to read that ❤️

Gracie W. Beit The Freedom Warrior (FAR co-founder) (1/2 FF)

Mar 21

•

I made an entire post sharing my opinion on how we already know the ending!!! There is proof for the end in the positive sense, would you like the link???

Vee

Mar 24

•

Replying to

That’s amazing! I think that Andrew again left it to our imaginations to decide. I 100% agree that the books ended on a positive note. However I don’t know if that means Janner is ressurected considering all the buildup to the moments of his death. But yeah I would love the link to read ur opinion ❤️❤️❤️❤️